Biography
Henry Jefferson McCarthy served six months on the Pennsylvania Superior Court. He was one of the original seven members appointed to the Pennsylvania Superior Court by Governor Daniel Hastings in June 1895.
Judge McCarthy was a prominent Philadelphia lawyer and judge of the Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas No. 3. McCarthy was born in the city of Philadelphia on October 11, 1845. He chose the law and immediately entered into its study under the preceptorship of eminent Philadelphia lawyer and former Pennsylvania Supreme Court Justice William A. Porter. After three years, McCarthy was admitted to the Philadelphia Bar, and he continued to practice in the city as an associate for Porter’s firm.
In June 1895, Governor Daniel Hastings appointed him to the newly established Pennsylvania Superior Court. Judge McCarthy was both the lone Democrat and lone Philadelphian on the bench, two characteristics that certainly influenced his appointment. It was noted at the time that the seven original judges were as “professional strangers,” however they met at Harrisburg that month to create rules and procedures for the operation of the court and determined which county’s cases would be heard at the five regional meeting sites: Harrisburg, Philadelphia, Pittsburgh, Scranton, and Williamsport.
He was not elected at the November 1895 election, so he returned to Philadelphia to practice law, but two years later on November 25, 1898, he was reinstated to the bench as an associate judge of the Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas No. 3. He passed away on July 21, 1903.