Biography
John Inscho Mitchell sat for only one session of the Pennsylvania Superior Court, although he legally held a judicial position on the court for almost three years. He won the election to a full 10-year term in 1899 and began his tenure on the Pennsylvania Superior Court in January 1900. Mitchell sat for one session of the court, which at the time was meeting in Scranton. He returned to his home in Wellsboro on January 24, 1900 and was regrettably stricken by paralysis; he did not return to the bench. On November 28, 1902, because of his disability, Mitchell voluntarily resigned from the Pennsylvania Superior Court.
He was born on July 28, 1838 in Tioga Township, Tioga County. At the time of the Civil War, he joined the 136th Pennsylvania Volunteer Infantry, and rose to the position of second lieutenant. His regiment fought the Confederates at Fredericksburg in December 1862 and at Chancellorsville in May 1863. He survived both bloody battles (in which over 29,000 Union soldiers were killed or wounded) and he was rewarded with a promotion to captain. Judge Mitchell was discharged at the end of the war and returned to Tioga County.
Following the war, Judge Mitchell settled in Wellsboro, the county seat, and continued his study in the law. He was admitted to the bar in September 1864. For the next four years Judge Mitchell conducted his law practice in Wellsboro and in 1868, he was elected to his first public office: District Attorney of Tioga County. In 1871, after serving three years as District Attorney, he campaigned for a seat in the state legislature, and was elected in November 1871 to the Pennsylvania House, a position he held for five years.
In November 1876, he was elected to the United States Congress. He was reelected in 1878. He retired from Congress after his second term. In 1881, he was elected to the United States Senate, where he served for a full six-year term, 1881-1887. He returned to the private practice of law following his term in the Senate.
Judge Mitchell died on August 20, 1907 in Wellsboro at the age of 69. He was buried in the Wellsboro Cemetery. Mitchell was a member of the Pennsylvania Bar Association, and was also active in the Wellsboro community serving for one year as an editor of the Agitator (the local weekly newspaper) and as secretary of the Wellsboro Agricultural Society.